India's top court upholds passive euthanasia, allows living wills in landmark judgment
11 March, 2018, 01:59 | Author: Charlene Valdez
Dr R N Tandon, secretary general of the IMA, said, "Just as every person has the right to life, they also have the right to die with dignity".
It means medical treatment can be withdrawn to hasten a person's death, if strict guidelines are followed.
He said the reason the court was impelled to recognize passive euthanasia and advance directives is that both bear a close association to the human urge to "live with dignity".
The CJI, while reading out the judgment, said that though there were four separate opinions of the bench but all the judges were unanimous that the "living will" should be permitted since a person can not be allowed to continue suffering in a comatose state when he or she doesn't wish to live. "For some, even their death could be a moment of celebration".
Though the government took the lead in decriminalising suicide and is ready with a draft legislation formalising passive euthanasia, it struck a contradictory note in opposing living wills, essentially a person's desire to exit from life at a point of no return.
India's top court delivered its verdict on a public interest litigation filed in 2005 by an NGO called Common Cause - to allow terminally-ill patients to "die with dignity" - and argued by lawyer Prashant Bhushan.
A living will is a written legal document by way of which a patient can categorically give consent in advance about the medical treatment s/he will be undergoing. "That apart, it will strengthen the mind of the treating doctors as they will be in a position to ensure, after being satisfied, that they are acting in a lawful manner", the CJI said. "Active euthanasia has more likelihood of being misused by unscrupulous individuals to attain their ulterior motives and therefore, may not be approved".
In Kochi, a senior priest of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church said legal recognition of "living will" made by terminally-ill patients for passive euthanasia is against the Indian culture.
Passive euthanasia involves withholding or discontinuing treatment for a terminally ill person where as active euthanasia involves injecting a lethal dose to a terminally ill person.
Also termed as "advance medical directive", it is a direction issued by an individual that "he or she shall or shall not be given medical treatment in future when or he she becomes terminally ill".
Aruna Shanbaug, 25, was a nurse in the King Edward Memorial Hospital in Mumbai when she was assaulted on November 27, 1973 by a sweeper. The apex court had, in 2011, first recognised passive euthanasia in the Aruna Shanbaug case.
After nearly two years of that, on February 15th, 2016 thecentreopined that it is a deliberate issue and the five judges bench led by the Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra heard the argument and reversed the previous verdict.
"Dying is a part of the living process and hence a part of Article 21. Everyone deserves to die peacefully", Anumeha said. "Following the Supreme Court ruling, the Centre will now have to frame guidelines on the matters around the issue, like who can carry out the process, what is the role of caregivers and such", says Jha.
Defence lawyers said Kumar, who was taken in only for questioning by the SIT, has been made an accused without any evidence. SIT produced him before the court today where he was remanded to five days police custody till 13th this month.
Porter finished with 12 points (5-of-17 shooting) and 8 rebounds, while younger brother Jontay Porter had 20 points and 8 boards. When Michael Porter Jr . checked into a college basketball game for the first time since November 10th, there was no score.
The Wildcats beat the Musketeers twice this season, but Xavier won the Big East regular-season title by one game over Villanova. St Marys (10 seed )- With the Gaels falling to BYU in the semi-finals of the WCC Tournament, they enter the bubble.
Meltzer said the United States' ability to shape the rules of trade in the Asia-Pacific region "is very much diminished". The pact was aimed at diminishing the increasing economic dominance of China in a rapidly growing part of the world.
Citing a source who asked not to be named, Bloomberg reported that the search for a buyer for the company had not been successful. The onetime biggest toy store in the world has been struggling to stay afloat in a changing retail environment (hi, Amazon! ).
But if a report from ESPN's Josina Anderson is to be believed, New England might not even kick the tires on the four-time All-Pro. But nothing materialized so the Seahawks instead chose to release Sherman with the hope that he may come back.
Warriors second-year guard Patrick McCaw will continue to wear a light brace on his injured left wrist for at least another week. Since then, Curry's ankles have been nothing more than a minor problem as he's risen to become one of the NBA's elite players.
She's consistently proven to be the most outspoken, going-against-tradition type this generation of the royal family has seen. Earlier today, we shared the secret nod to International Women's Day which featured in the ensemble Meghan Markle wore today.
When asked if the Cosby allegations "tainted" her memories of The Cosby Show , she said, "No, it's exactly as I remember it". She posed topless in Interview magazine, and had a nude sex scene in Angel Heart , which Cosby openly disapproved of.
In a real life situation that nearly echoed in this week's finale, Roberson wrote, "He'd often see both of us on the same day". Then, it was time for a chat: Why had he chosen Becca? "And so I've moved on from that", she admitted.
Waymo moves beyond driverless taxis with trucking program
There, the trailers are hitched onto self-driving trucks for long highway hauls, according to the San Francisco-based company. Waymo is starting out small with this pilot test, using these semi trucks to carry cargo destined for Google's data centers.
Roger Stone says he didn't ask Nunberg to protect him
Nunberg was speaking out to explain his frustration with the ongoing Russian Federation investigation by Robert Mueller . I understand she was just doing her job, and I think she does a very good job under rough circumstances.
Pelicans Star Anthony Davis Has Sprained Ankle, Is Day-to-Day
New Orleans has won 10 consecutive games and its performance has really made an impression on Warriors forward Draymond Green . He briefly remained in Wednesday's game, but was shortly taken to the team's locker room with 3:11 remaining in the third.
Pyongyang or Panmunjeom for Kim-Trump meeting?
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, travelling in Africa, just hours before said the U.S. was "a long ways" from direct talks. Calling the planned US-North Korea talks a "step forward", Geng urged the two sides to build mutual trust through dialogue.
Gunman takes 3 hostages at largest US veterans home
About 1,000 veterans from conflicts spanning from World War II to Operation Enduring Freedom are said to call the facility home. Jan Thornton, 51, said her father is a WWII veteran who lives in the skilled nursing section of the facility.
ICC charges Warner, De Kock for Durban dispute
Australia coach Darren Lehmann threw his support behind Warner on Tuesday, declaring he will continue as vice-captain. Some called it immature and others "mind games", but all agreed that it had been taken too far.
Sydney Airport delays as computer glitch causes terminal chaos
The airport is now experiencing technical issues at security and check-in desks, causing major interruptions to outbound flights. Virgin Australia said it was holding some flights to minimise disruptions and was working to re-accommodate those affected.